New York Pizza Pub

This place was the best pizza in town. I have been coming since they opened. But ever since Rich sold the place the staff isn't as friendly the pizza isn't consistent they never cook them all the way or too much. For some reason sometimes the dough is super thick. To top it all off the staff purposely give extremely long wait times 2 hours before they close to try and scare people off. Its so obvious. Who says "It will be like a 45 50 or 60 min wait. I have no problem waiting but its obvious what they are doing.

Let me start by saying this used to be the top pizza place in New Braunfels. There is nothing, in my opinion, better than an authentic NY pie and this place used to deliver that. Huge foldable slice with enough greasy cheese that it could take a napkin to sop some of the grease off! Ah those were the days. Fast forward to the latest visit and while the place has been eclipsed for a while by several better quality pizza places which while maybe not “New York”, took their pizza to a level this place wasn’t hitting. Now however I’m almost ashamed to say, this place is a shadow of its former self. The slice isn’t foldable anymore because it’s more like a cracker it’s been in the oven so long. The sauce is uninspired and lacks flavor. The cheese is very very light, frankly, tastes like maybe they changed up suppliers there. Our order of mozzarella sticks had the flavor that lets you know it’s past time to clean the fryer. Maybe this is just the final way of saying it’s time I let this place slip completely off my rotation. As I mentioned earlier it’s slipped already just due to some newer stellar performers in town but no, I think the quality here has gone down enough that I don’t think I’ll be back. I’ll still look fondly on what had been.

We dont usually diNe in here, but we will absolutely drive across town for a pie 😅Keep up the good work guys!

Pick your kid up here after the dance!!!